top of page
Search
Writer's pictureMindset Media

15 Reasons Your Keyword Rankings are Fluctuating Like Crazy

keyword ranking fluctuating

Quicklinks:

 

Fluctuating keyword rankings can be frustrating for SEO practitioners. Understanding the reasons behind these fluctuations is crucial for developing effective strategies. This article explores the 15 key factors contributing to the ups and downs of your keyword rankings, helping you navigate through them with confidence and clarity.


By identifying and addressing these factors, you can:

●  Improve your site's performance

●  Enhance user experience

●  Build a robust backlink profile

For small businesses in Calgary, implementing SEO strategies is even more crucial. The 6 reasons why SEO for small business in Calgary is essential for growth will help you level the playing field and beat the competition!


1. On-Site Issues

When you observe significant changes in your keyword rankings, the first area to investigate is your own website. By effectively monitoring and analyzing keyword shifts, you can gain insights into potential on-site issues. Here's how you can address these concerns:


The Significance of Technical SEO

Technical SEO plays a fundamental role in maintaining stable keyword rankings. Regularly auditing your site for technical issues like broken links, duplicate content, and slow page load times can prevent rankings from fluctuating wildly.


Emphasizing Content Quality and Relevance

Search engines prioritize high-quality, relevant content. It's essential to ensure that your content is up-to-date, informative, and aligned with the keywords you're targeting. Regularly updating old posts and adding fresh, valuable content can improve your keyword stability.


Enhancing User Experience and Site Performance

User experience (UX) metrics such as bounce rate, time on site, and mobile-friendliness have a direct impact on your keyword rankings. Improving site navigation, ensuring quick load times, and providing a seamless user experience can positively influence your rankings.


If you require specialized assistance in improving these aspects, consider reaching out to a digital marketing team that helps companies grow by creating and implementing customized marketing strategies while providing ongoing professional expertise.


For more detailed insights into SEO practices, you can explore our extensive collection of articles in the SEO blog category.


2. Changes in Your Backlink Profile

A strong backlink profile is crucial for SEO success, but it can also cause fluctuations in your keyword rankings. It's important to regularly analyze your backlinks to maintain a healthy link profile and minimize any negative effects on your rankings.


Strategies for Building Links

Having a solid plan for building links is essential. Instead of going after a large number of low-quality links, focus on acquiring high-quality backlinks from reputable sources. Remember, quality is always more important than quantity when it comes to backlinks.


The Debate: Quality vs Quantity

There's an ongoing debate about whether it's better to have high-quality backlinks or a large quantity of backlinks. Here's the truth:


●  High-quality backlinks from authoritative sites carry more weight and have a significant positive impact on your rankings.

●  On the other hand, low-quality or spammy links can harm your SEO efforts.


Making Sense of Google Search Console Data

Google Search Console (previously known as Google Webmaster Tools) is an invaluable tool for understanding link-related problems and the overall quality of your content. By regularly monitoring this data, you can identify harmful links that should be disavowed and gain insights into how your link profile affects keyword trends.


Note: Google Search Console is a free tool provided by Google that helps website owners monitor and maintain their site's presence in search results.


Stay tuned for the next section where we'll discuss the importance of content optimization in SEO.


3. Impact of Google Algorithm Changes

Fluctuations in keyword rankings are a common occurrence due to Google's constant refinement of its search algorithm. Understanding the types of algorithm updates that influence your rankings can help you adapt effectively.


Types of Algorithm Updates

1.  Daily Manual Tweaks: Google makes small daily adjustments to improve search quality. These tweaks may not be announced but can cause noticeable ranking shifts.

2.  Machine Learning Adjustments: Google's machine learning algorithms, like RankBrain, continuously learn and adapt, impacting search results based on user behaviour.

3.  Major Releases: Significant updates like Panda, Penguin, and BERT are rolled out periodically and can lead to substantial ranking changes.


Surviving the Volatility of Google's Algorithm

To navigate through these fluctuations:

●  Stay Informed: Keep up with industry news and Google’s official announcements to anticipate major changes.

●  Regular Audits: Conduct frequent SEO audits to identify issues early and adjust strategies accordingly.


Strategies for Future-Proofing Your SEO

1.  Focus on Quality Content: Ensure your content is valuable, relevant, and well-optimized.

2.  Build a Robust Backlink Profile: Engage in ethical link-building practices to establish authority.

3.  Enhance User Experience: Improve site speed, mobile-friendliness, and overall user experience.


In addition to these strategies, it's important to leverage other resources that can contribute to your online success. For instance, professional social media marketing services in Calgary can greatly enhance your visibility and reach on platforms like Facebook by generating leads & conversions through targeted campaigns. Furthermore, utilizing free Google tools for business growth can optimize your online presence and enable you to make data-driven decisions, from leveraging Google Analytics for insights into user behaviour to utilizing Google Trends for market research. Such resources, when combined with the aforementioned SEO strategies, can significantly improve your chances of success in the ever-evolving digital landscape.


4. Competitive Landscape Shifts

The SEO industry is always changing, with new competitors appearing and established ones losing their positions. In this section, we'll explore how these shifts can affect your keyword rankings and share tips on how you can stay ahead of the competition.


Understanding Your Competitors

It's important to have a good understanding of your competitive landscape. Regularly analyzing your competitors can help you:

●  Identify new players in the market.

●  Discover which keywords they're focusing on.

●  Study their content strategies and backlink profiles.


By keeping an eye on both new entrants and the decline of existing competitors, you can adjust your strategy accordingly. Tools like Ahrefs or SEMrush can be extremely helpful for this type of analysis.


Building a Strong Brand

Having a strong brand identity is not only about standing out from your competitors but also about building trust and loyalty with your audience. Here are some key strategies to consider:

●  Developing unique value propositions that set you apart.

●  Improving the user experience on your website.

●  Maintaining consistent branding across all marketing channels.


For more information on creating effective digital marketing strategies, you can check out Mindset Media, a reputable digital marketing agency in Calgary that specializes in implementing custom marketing strategies including SEO, PPC, and Social Media Marketing.


Staying Agile in SEO

Maintaining a strong SEO strategy in a constantly changing landscape requires flexibility and adaptability. Here are a few tips to help you navigate through these shifts:


1.  Stay updated: Keep yourself informed about the latest trends and algorithm updates in the SEO industry.

2.  Monitor your performance: Regularly track your keyword rankings and website traffic to identify any sudden changes.

3.  Optimize existing content: Continuously optimize your existing web pages to ensure they are still relevant and valuable. You can start by learning how to write an effective title tag for your website, as it is a crucial aspect of SEO.

4.  Explore new opportunities: Look for untapped keywords or emerging topics that align with your target audience's interests.

5.  Build quality backlinks: Focus on acquiring high-quality backlinks from authoritative websites in your industry.


By staying proactive and adapting to these changes, you can minimize the impact of new competitors and take advantage of opportunities created by the decline of existing ones.


5. User Behaviour and Preference Changes

Keyword rankings are not solely determined by algorithms; they are also influenced by user behaviour signals. A surge of traffic for certain queries can lead to sudden trends, causing fluctuations in rankings. For instance, if a new product gains popularity, search volume for related keywords may spike, leading Google to adjust rankings based on this fresh data.


Aligning your SEO efforts with evolving user preferences involves:


Monitoring User Trends

Regularly analyze shifts in user behaviour using tools like Google Analytics. Look for patterns in search queries that indicate changing interests or needs.


Enhancing User Experience (UX)

A positive UX can significantly impact your rankings. Ensure your website is easy to navigate, loads quickly, and provides valuable content to keep users engaged.


Adapting Content Strategy

Update your content to reflect current user interests. Incorporate trending topics and frequently asked questions to address what users are actively searching for.


Understanding these dynamics helps you stay ahead of the curve. For instance, integrating pay-per-click strategies from Calgary's Expert Google Ads Company can complement your organic efforts by driving targeted traffic and providing insights into user preferences.


The role of user experience in SEO cannot be overstated. A seamless, intuitive site encourages longer visits and reduces bounce rates, signalling to search engines that your content is relevant and valuable.


6. Seasonality and Keyword Ranking Fluctuating

Many industries experience seasonal variations in search volume and competition levels, leading to fluctuations in keyword rankings. Temporal interest plays a significant role in these shifts. For example, retail websites may see a spike in certain product queries during holiday seasons or back-to-school periods. This influx of seasonal traffic can create temporary surges or drops in rankings based on current user behaviour.


Adapting Your SEO Strategies

To navigate these fluctuations, consider the following:

1.  Seasonal Keyword Research: Identify keywords that are likely to peak during specific times of the year. Tools like Google Trends can be invaluable for spotting these patterns.

2.  Content Calendar Planning: Align your content creation efforts with anticipated seasonal trends. Publish relevant articles, blog posts, or product pages well ahead of peak seasons to capture early interest.

3.  Creating Evergreen Content: While seasonal content is important, evergreen content remains crucial for maintaining steady traffic year-round. Ensure your website has a mix of both to balance short-term spikes with long-term stability.


By understanding the impact of seasonality on SEO performance, you can better prepare and adapt your strategies to maintain consistency in your keyword rankings despite temporal fluctuations.

7. The Role of New Content

Publishing fresh content on your website can have both positive and negative repercussions on your keyword rankings. Search engines perceive new content as a signal of activity and relevance, but this can trigger complex machinery that affects your overall site ranking.


Impact of New Content on Rankings


Positive Effects:

●  Increased Visibility: New content can target additional keywords, increasing your site's visibility in search results.

●  Updated Information: Fresh content keeps your site relevant and up-to-date, which search engines favour.

●  User Engagement: Engaging and valuable content can boost user interaction metrics such as time-on-site and click-through rates.


Negative Effects:

●  Volatility in Rankings: Introducing new content might temporarily disrupt existing rankings as search engines re-evaluate your site.

●  Content Cannibalization: If not managed properly, new content might compete with existing pages for the same keywords, leading to diluted rankings.


Best Practices for Optimizing New Content for SEO:

●  Keyword Research: Identify and utilize relevant keywords that complement your existing content strategy.

●  Quality Over Quantity: Focus on creating high-quality, informative, and engaging content rather than simply increasing volume.

●  Internal Linking: Use internal links to connect new content with related existing pages to distribute authority and improve navigation.

●  Regular Updates: Continuously update new content based on performance metrics and evolving user preferences to maintain its relevance.


Consistently applying these best practices will help maximize the SEO value of your new content while minimizing potential volatility in rankings.


8. Content Removal and Pruning

Removing outdated or underperforming content through regular audits is a crucial SEO maintenance task that can contribute to improved keyword rankings. This process, often referred to as content pruning, involves identifying and eliminating content that no longer adds value to your site.


Practical Tips for Conducting Effective Content Audits:

1.  Identify Low-Performing Content: Use tools like Google Analytics and Google Search Console to pinpoint pages with low traffic and engagement.

2.  Evaluate Relevance: Assess whether the content is still relevant to your target audience. If it's outdated, consider updating or repurposing it.

3.  Check for Quality: Remove or improve content that doesn't meet current quality standards.

4.  Monitor Impact: After pruning, keep an eye on your rankings and traffic to ensure stability.


Balancing consistency with freshness in your content strategy helps maintain ranking stability while ensuring your site remains valuable and engaging for users. Regular audits not only boost rankings but also enhance user experience by presenting them with up-to-date and high-quality information.


9. Link Profile Cleanup

Regularly auditing your links is crucial for maintaining a strong backlink profile that supports your SEO efforts. By reviewing and removing poor-quality links, you can stabilize your rankings and potentially improve them.


How Link Audits Affect Rankings

Conducting a thorough link audit involves assessing the quality and relevance of the websites linking to you. Here's why it matters:


1.  Identifying Harmful Links: By analyzing your link profile, you can spot any harmful or spammy links that may be dragging down your rankings.

2.  Preventing Penalties: Removing these toxic links promptly can help you avoid search engine penalties and maintain your ranking position.


Strategies for Effective Link Cleanup

When it comes to cleaning up your link profile, here are some tactics you can employ:


1.  Using Link Analysis Tools: Tools like Ahrefs, Moz, or SEMrush can provide insights into the quality of your backlinks. They can help you identify low-quality or toxic links that need to be removed.

2.  Disavowing Harmful Links: If you're unable to remove certain bad links manually, you can use Google Search Console's disavow tool. This tells Google to ignore those links when assessing your website's authority.


The Importance of Building Quality Backlinks

While removing bad links is important, it's equally crucial to focus on acquiring good-quality backlinks. Here's why:


1.  Enhancing Your Authority: Search engines consider backlinks as votes of confidence from other websites. Getting links from authoritative and relevant sites within your industry can boost your own site's authority.

2.  Improving Your Visibility: When reputable websites link to your content, it increases its visibility to a wider audience. This can lead to more organic traffic and potential customers.


Here are some strategies you can use to attract high-quality backlinks:


1.  Guest Blogging: Writing informative articles for other websites in your niche can help you earn valuable backlinks.

2.  Influencer Outreach: Collaborating with influencers or industry experts to create content can result in them linking back to your site.

3.  Content Marketing: Creating compelling and shareable content assets such as infographics, videos, or research studies can naturally attract backlinks from other online sources.


Maintaining a clean link profile involves both removing bad links and continually building good ones. This dual approach is key to improving your website's visibility and authority over time.


10. The Fundamentals of Google Search and SEO

To understand why your keyword rankings fluctuate, it's important to first grasp how Google's search engine works and the essential role that SEO plays.


Here are some key concepts to help you understand the basics:


Search Algorithms

Google uses complex systems called algorithms to gather information from its search index and quickly provide the best possible results for a search query. These algorithms take into account various factors, such as keywords, the quality of content, and user experience.


Ranking Factors

Several elements determine where your website appears on a Search Engine Result Page (SERP). These factors include:


●  On-page SEO factors: This includes things like metadata (title tags, meta descriptions), headings, and the relevance of your content to the search query.

●  Off-page factors: These are external signals such as backlinks from other websites that indicate the authority and credibility of your site.

●  Technical aspects: This refers to the technical setup of your website, including its speed and mobile-friendliness.


Link Signals

Links serve as recommendations or votes of confidence for your website. When reputable sites link back to your content, it signals to Google that your information is trustworthy and valuable, which can positively impact your rankings.


The Anatomy of a Search Engine Result Page (SERP):

It's also helpful to understand the different components of a typical SERP:


1.  Paid Results: These are advertisements that appear at the top or bottom of the page, usually marked with an "Ad" label.

2.  Organic Results: These are web pages listed in order of relevance based on Google's algorithm. They are not paid placements.

3.  Featured Snippets: For certain queries, Google may display a summarized answer directly on the SERP, extracted from a relevant web page. This box is positioned above the organic results and aims to provide quick information to users.

4.  Local Pack: When a search query has local intent (e.g., "restaurants near me"), Google may show a group of local business listings with additional details like ratings and opening hours. Some people refer to this as the "Snack Pack".


All these elements work together to present users with comprehensive search results, so understanding them is crucial for effective SEO strategies.


11. Finding the Right Balance Between Ads and Organic SEO

Paid advertisements can have an impact on your organic visibility and keyword rankings. It's important to find a balance between running ad campaigns and maintaining a strong SEO foundation.


Understanding How Ads Affect Search Results

Here are some key points to keep in mind:


●  Starting/Stopping Ads: Making sudden changes to your ad strategy can cause shifts in your organic rankings. Running high-volume ads can drive traffic and potentially improve organic positions, while stopping ads might lead to a temporary dip.

●  Organic SEO: Relying too heavily on ads without focusing on SEO can harm your organic rankings. It's essential to prioritize both strategies and ensure they complement each other.

●  Effective Ads: Well-targeted ads have the potential to generate valuable traffic and backlinks, which can positively impact your overall SEO performance. However, it's important to avoid going overboard with ads, especially ones that disrupt the user experience and may harm your rankings.


Achieving the right balance between these elements requires constant monitoring and adjustment. You want both your ads and organic efforts to work together smoothly without conflicting with each other.


12. The Aftermath of a Link Audit

Performing a link audit is essential for maintaining a healthy backlink profile. However, the process can be tricky. Removing toxic links strengthens your site's SEO, but accidentally removing good links can negatively impact your keyword rankings.


Potential Consequences:

●  Lost Authority: Good links contribute to your domain authority. Removing these can lower your site's credibility.

●  Ranking Drops: A sudden decrease in high-quality backlinks can result in significant ranking drops.


To mitigate these risks:

1.  Thorough Analysis: Use tools like Ahrefs or SEMrush to differentiate between toxic and valuable links accurately.

2.  Diversify Your Links: Relying on a diverse range of backlinks can cushion the impact if some good links are accidentally removed.

3.  Regular Monitoring: Continuously monitor your backlink profile to promptly address any issues that arise.

By following these steps, you can ensure that your link audit has a positive rather than detrimental effect on your SEO performance.


13. URL Changes and Redirects

Making changes to the URLs of your web pages can lead to temporary disruptions in your keyword rankings. This happens because search engines need time to reindex the new URLs and understand their relevance. Proper implementation of URL changes and redirects is crucial for minimizing negative impacts on your organic visibility.


Best Practices for Implementing URL Changes

●  Maintain Consistency: Ensure that the new URLs are SEO-friendly, concise, and relevant to the content.

●  301 Redirects: Use 301 redirects to guide search engines and users from the old URL to the new one. This helps preserve link equity.

●  Update Internal Links: Adjust all internal links to point to the new URLs to avoid broken links and improve user experience.


The Role of Canonical Tags in URL Management

Canonical tags help search engines identify the primary version of a page when duplicate or similar content exists across multiple URLs. Proper use of canonical tags prevents issues related to duplicate content, which can otherwise confuse search engines and dilute your ranking power.


By carefully managing URL changes and employing redirects effectively, you can mitigate ranking fluctuations and maintain steady organic traffic during transitional periods.


14. Dealing with Search Penalties

Getting penalized by Google can cause a significant drop in your keyword rankings. To effectively address and bounce back from these penalties, it's important to understand the different types of search penalties.


Types of Google Penalties:

There are two main types of penalties that Google can impose:


1.  Automatic Penalties: These are triggered by algorithmic updates when your site violates Google's guidelines.

2.  Manual Penalties: These are imposed by Google reviewers who identify non-compliance during manual checks.


Identifying Search Penalties:

Being able to recognize when you've been hit with a search penalty is crucial. Here are some ways to identify them:


1.  Use tools like Google Search Console to check for notifications about manual actions.

2.  Monitor sudden and significant drops in organic traffic or keyword rankings, as these could be signs of an automatic penalty.


Prevention and Recovery Strategies:

Of course, it's always better to prevent penalties from happening in the first place. Here are some strategies to help you do that:


1.  Conduct regular site audits to ensure that your website is following all of Google's guidelines.

2.  Remove or disavow any spammy backlinks that could potentially trigger penalties.

3.  Focus on creating high-quality content and steer clear of any black-hat SEO tactics.


By taking these proactive measures, you'll be able to minimize the risk of getting penalized and also speed up the recovery process if you ever do get hit with one.


15. Protecting Your Website Against Negative SEO Attacks

Your competitors may use malicious SEO techniques like spammy link building to harm your keyword rankings. It's important to know about negative SEO attacks so you can safeguard your website.


Negative SEO Attacks:

●  Spam Links Bombing: Competitors might use spam links to harm your site's ranking. These links are often irrelevant and low-quality, leading search engines to devalue your site.


Proactive Measures:

●  Regular Link Audits: Regularly check your backlink profile to identify and remove toxic links.

●  Disavow Tool in Google Search Console: Use this tool to inform Google about the harmful links you want disregarded.


The Future of SEO: Emerging trends and opportunities in SEO demand a vigilant and adaptive approach. Stay updated with the latest strategies to counteract negative tactics and maintain a strong online presence.


Conclusion

In the ever-changing world of SEO, it's common to see shifts in keyword rankings. Instead of feeling discouraged by these changes, it's important to take a comprehensive and long-term approach to optimization. This means focusing on creating valuable content, building authoritative backlinks, and ensuring a smooth user experience. These factors are the main drivers of consistent visibility in search results.


To successfully navigate through the ups and downs of keyword rankings, remember these key points:


1.  Embrace Change: Understand that fluctuations are a normal part of the SEO process.

2.  Stay Agile: Continuously adjust your strategies to stay ahead of the competition.

3.  Prioritize User Value: Always prioritize creating high-quality content and delivering an excellent user experience.


With vigilance, adaptability, and a focus on user value, you can confidently handle keyword ranking fluctuations and strengthen your SEO efforts for long-term success.


Frequently Asked Questions

What are some on-site issues that can affect keyword shifts?

Some on-site issues that can impact keyword shifts include the importance of technical SEO, content quality and relevance, and user experience and site performance.

How can backlink profile changes affect keyword rankings?

What types of Google algorithm changes can influence keyword rankings?

How do sudden shifts in the competitive landscape impact keyword rankings?

What role does user behavior and preference changes play in keyword rankings?

How does seasonality impact SEO performance and keyword rankings?


Comments


bottom of page